El Foro

Title basically describes the situation, not sure if this is the right subreddit for this kinda question but I’m desperate.

For context, I have been playing on my Xbox with my controller plugged into my Mac as a sort of wired connection station, the controller I have been using for years finally kicked the bucket and I had to get a new one, been using the new one and used the batteries that came with it, once they died I went back to the bread and butter, or so I thought.

I stupidly made the incredibly educated decision of just clicking the first option I saw out of the corner of my eye and now my controller has been paired to my Mac. Is there any way to undo this every guide I’ve looked up online says to remove it from Bluetooth but it’s literally not there.